Zachary D’Onofrio sings “Golden Slumbers” by The Beatles, then a duet of “Falling” by Harry Styles with Catie Turner

He was called “Sinatra Boy,” “Mr. Surprising” and “Zach Attack” by the judges, but will we be able to call him...the next American Idol? Zachary D’Onofrio auditions with his rendition of “Golden Slumbers” by The Beatles, then brings in his girlfriend and former American Idol semi-finalist, Catie Turner, for a duet of his second song, “Falling” by Harry Styles. Katy Perry and Lionel Richie compare Zachary to a turtle, saying they want to see him come out of his shell. Will slow and steady win the race to be the next American Idol?